24 Hour Emergency Contact 812-399-1152

10 Tips To Help You Choose The Right Roofing Contractor


The biggest obstacle to a successful roofing project is choosing the right contractor. After a damaging storm, you need to quickly get your home back to normal. But that doesn’t mean choosing the first contractor that knocks on your door. Finding one that is trustworthy, honest, and professional may seem difficult — but we’re here to help. Check out these important tips to help protect yourself, your home, and your wallet.

1. Get local referrals. There’s a reduced chance of issues or scams when you choose a contractor from your community. They’re more familiar with local rules and code regulations and have an established relationship with area crews and suppliers.

2. Look for manufacturer designations. Manufacturer designations are considered a badge of honor because the contractor must meet certain minimum requirements to be factory certified (although some manufacturers have more stringent requirements than others). GAF strictly enforces and verifies a contractor’s license, insurance, and years in business before granting the designation of factory-certified contractor. In fact, less than 5% of roofing contractors per market qualify to be recognized as GAF factory-certified contractors.

3. Research Better Business Bureau (BBB) ratings. Some contractors blow into town right after a storm looking for work, so it’s important to look them up on the BBB website and make sure they have a good score. Stay away from contractors who don’t exist on BBB.org. GAF factory-certified contractors are required to maintain satisfactory ratings with the BBB in order to retain their certification.

4. Get an extensive warranty. Not all contractors can offer manufacturer comprehensive warranties. Most manufacturer warranties only cover the shingles for a very short time. Comprehensive warranties like the System Plus Limited Warranty, the Silver Pledge™ Limited Warranty, or the Golden Pledge® Limited Warranty can cover all of the GAF Materials against manufacturing defects for as long as 50 years.* In addition, with the Silver Pledge™ Limited Warranty, the contractor’s workmanship is covered for as long as 10 years; with the Golden Pledge® Limited Warranty, the contractor’s workmanship is covered for as long as 25 years (in the case of defective installation that causes leaks).*

5. Be concerned about safety. Contractors without a training or safety program may not be the best option to work on your home. That is why GAF created CARE, the Center for the Advancement of Roofing Excellence, a fulltime training and education team dedicated to training GAF factory-certified contractors in safe installation practices and the installation of high-quality roofs. To date, CARE has trained over 200,000 professionals. GAF is the only roofing manufacturer with a dedicated team of trainers in the industry.

6. Check for proper license and insurance. The contractor should have insurance for all employees and subcontractors, and be able to provide a copy of their insurance certificate for validation. Not having adequate insurance could potentially lead to litigation between a contractor and homeowner if a roofing employee has an injury at the home. Most states require licensing for contractors but that doesn’t stop unlicensed contractors from attempting to do roofing work. In states where licenses are required, make sure your contractor provides you with a copy of their license, and confirm their status online. GAF factory-certified contractors must maintain appropriate levels of Workers Compensation, at least $1 million worth of General Liability coverage, and have proper state and city licensing where they are performing work.**

7. Pay your deductible.  Any contractor who claims that they can handle a repair without having the homeowner pay their insurance deductible is committing insurance fraud and a felony, and endangering the homeowner. The insurance deductible is the responsibility of the insured, and the contractor should reflect that in the quote without inflating the estimate to cover all or part of the deductible.

8. Handle your own claim. A contractor who says they are “a claim specialist” or can “handle your insurance claim” may be breaking the law. In most states, it’s illegal for contractors to act on behalf of the homeowner when negotiating an insurance claim. Any contractor who opens the door to potential legal action is not acting in your best interest.

9. Don’t give in to pressure. Watch out for a contractor who pressures you to sign a contract before the insurance company has estimated the damage. Some contractors say they can work with whatever your insurance company settles upon, however, the homeowner needs to ensure it’s not just any amount, but the right amount. The contractor should thoroughly examine the home and check that the insurance adjuster didn’t miss any damages.

10. Know your material choices.  A contractor who doesn’t offer you different shingle options is not looking out for your best interests. The style and color of the shingle you install can affect the resale value of your home. If the insurance company is paying for a new roof, it may be the perfect time to make a change and upgrade to a more unique style that suits your taste. GAF factory-certified contractors can offer extensive design and color choices for your home. If future storm protection is important, ask about GAF ArmorShield™ Series Shingles. Go to gaf.com and check out the choices now, so you’re ready. Knowledge is power.

Blog Attachments


    • Tucson Rubberized Coatings

      Nice tips! I totally agree that before you let a contractor do his work you need to make sure he has a proper insurance. I need a roofer for my old house in the countryside and I will check all of his documents before he starts working. Thanks for the advice!

    • Tucson Rubberized Coatings

      Thanks for the information to be competent enough to choose the best roofer. Our house is about 1/2 way built and we need to find a company to do a new roof installation. That is a great idea to make sure that the roofer has formal training and that they have a legitimate roofing certification too.

    • Joe Braxton

      My wife and I have been having problems with our roof, and we haven’t been sure what to start looking for. I liked that you had mentioned that it can be helpful to get recommendations from a family member or friends on who to hire. I’ll have to start looking around for roofers in the area that can help us out with our problems, and I’ll be sure to talk with my family and friends first.

Leave us a comment